Evidence explorer

Which public bottles match this evidence brief, and what still needs verification?

Live catalog tdsi-988807bc30ee

Reset to wine

Current answer

4 public records

Scope: Wine · Unresolved conflict · Tasted and scored · Conflicting grape claims

4 public records match. Documented named removal method: 3 of 4 eligible records. Documented exact residual claim: 0 of 4 records. Firsthand scores: 4.

Evidence gaps stay in the denominator. Method missing or withheld: 0; method conflicts: 1; ABV missing or unsupported: 0; ABV conflicts: 4; documented grapes: 0 of 4 wine records.

Pass the evidence on

Share this exact research brief

The copied counts are dated. Its permalink is labeled as a live view because catalog evidence can change after it is sent.

Open permalink
Preview plain-text brief

Supporting bottles

4 bottles

Page 1 of 1 · Each claim opens its source trail.

Edenvale

Edenvale Sparkling Cuvee

Public product ID TDS-0419

86/100
Origin
Australia
Style
Sparkling
Classification
Dealcoholized
Importer
Lionstone International, Lake Forest, Illinois
Availability
Producer shop checked 25 Oct 2026
Removal method Other documented method Method conflict
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-10-25
Supports
Edenvale names a GoLo heat-pump that separates alcohol, dealcoholized liquid, and essence, then returns the essence.
Open dispute
Edenvale names a GoLo heat-pump and does not name a spinning cone. Laithwaites says the wine goes through a custom spinning cone column. We follow Edenvale.
Residual ABV 0.25% Unresolved conflict
Evidence
Bottle verified
Checked
2026-10-25
Supports
The source is associated with this field; no public supporting sentence is stored.
Open dispute
The Edenvale page says less than 0.5% ABV. The US bottle prints 0.25%. We print 0.25%.
Grape varieties Not documented Conflicting grape claims
Evidence
No field-level source
Supports
No public supporting sentence is stored for this field.
Open dispute
The Edenvale page says selected South Eastern Australian grapes and does not name a variety. Laithwaites names Sémillon. We do not print a grape.

Hand on Heart

Hand on Heart Rosé

Public product ID TDS-0634

84/100
Origin
United States
Style
Rosé
Classification
Dealcoholized
Availability
Seen at Better Rhodes checked 10 Nov 2026
Removal method Spinning cone Documented named removal method
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-10
Supports
The source is associated with this field; no public supporting sentence is stored.
Residual ABV <0.5% Unresolved conflict
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-10
Supports
The source is associated with this field; no public supporting sentence is stored.
Open dispute
Serendipity structured field prints 0.5%; the same page’s winemaking sentence says under 0.5% ABV. The 2020 sell sheet and Better Rhodes print less than / <0.5%. Public field follows the less-than ceiling.
Grape varieties 97% Muscat, 3% Pinot Noir (Serendipity Wines NV trade listing). A 2020 producer sell sheet and Better Rhodes instead list 99% Chardonnay and 1% Cabernet Sauvignon. Conflicting grape claims
Evidence
Distributor sourced
Checked
2026-11-10
Supports
The source is associated with this field; no public supporting sentence is stored.
Open dispute
Serendipity NV trade listing (2026-11-10): 97% Muscat, 3% Pinot Noir. Archived 2020 producer sell sheet and living Better Rhodes page: 99% Chardonnay and 1% Cabernet Sauvignon. Not reconciled.

Kolonne Null

Kolonne Null Tempranillo

Public product ID TDS-0559

90/100
Origin
Spain
Style
Tempranillo
Classification
Dealcoholized
Availability
Producer shop checked 5 Nov 2026
Removal method Vacuum distillation Documented named removal method
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-05
Supports
Both sentences are kept. No other machine is named.
Residual ABV <0.5% Unresolved conflict
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-05
Supports
The product page prints "Alcohol-free (<0,5%)" and the category line "Dealcoholized wine (<0,5 % vol.)." The laboratory page’s 0.3% maximum is a range statement and is kept in discrepancies.
Open dispute
Both claims are retained. No exact residual is stored. The public figure is the product page ceiling, under 0.5%.
Grape varieties Tempranillo Conflicting grape claims
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-05
Supports
The rendered page prints "Grape variety: Tempranillo." The product description on the same URL prints "Grapes: Tempranillo, Syrah." Both claims are retained.
Open dispute
Both claims are retained. No blend percentage is stored.

Wölffer Estate

Wölffer Estate Spring in a Bottle Rosé Sparkling

Public product ID TDS-0025

85/100
Origin
Germany
Style
Sparkling rosé
Classification
Dealcoholized
Availability
Producer shop checked 8 Nov 2026
Removal method Vacuum distillation Documented named removal method
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-08
Supports
The source is associated with this field; no public supporting sentence is stored.
Residual ABV 0.2% Unresolved conflict
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-08
Supports
The difference remains unresolved; the page’s figure is not assumed to be a rounded threshold.
Open dispute
Rechecked 2026-11-08. The official 2023 technical sheet still prints Alc. by Volume 0.2%. The live product page wine specs still print Alcohol by Volume: 0.5, while the description says under 0.5% Alc. The profile retains the technical sheet’s exact 0.2% declaration. This difference is unresolved; no rounding convention or formulation change is inferred. The historical Total Wine listing printed 0.0%, but was blocked/unreachable when checked on 2026-09-21.
Grape varieties 75% Pinot Noir, 15% Saint Laurent, 10% field blend of Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon; organically grown Conflicting grape claims
Evidence
Producer documented
Checked
2026-11-08
Supports
The source is associated with this field; no public supporting sentence is stored.
Open dispute
Rechecked 2026-11-08. The official 2023 technical sheet lists 75% Pinot Noir, 15% Saint Laurent, and 10% Merlot/Cabernet Sauvignon field blend. The GRAPE importer page still lists Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier, Saint Laurent, and Dornfelder. The profile retains the technical sheet blend. No winner is inferred.

Global overview

Catalog coverage, with the gaps left visible

635 publicly inspectable records. 21 work-in-progress records are excluded. Catalog composition is coverage—not market size, share, sales, demand, or launches.

Recorded catalog growth

Catalog coverage and firsthand tasted-and-scored coverage are separate series. A catalog addition is a TDS coverage event—not a market launch.

Launch milestone 2026-09-18 First recorded bottle; not a full inventory snapshot.

No earlier comparable inventory snapshots are on record. The chart starts with today’s live snapshot; the missing interval is intentional.

View snapshot table and sources
DatePublic catalogTasted & scoredScopeSource
2026-11-13 635 365 public_catalog_v1 Live catalog · tdsi-988807bc30ee

Field-by-field completeness

Evidence states—not a disclosure leaderboard

Completeness is not quality, safety, honesty, or proof that one process makes a better drink. These explicit rules are groundwork for a future Transparency Index, not an index itself.

Removal method

3/4 removal-eligible records have a documented named method. Inapplicable and unknown applicability remain outside that denominator.

Residual ABV

0/4 records have a sourced exact residual claim without an open ABV conflict. Label-only declarations and ceilings stay separate.

Lab-tested residual share is not yet measurable from current records; a declaration is not called a lab result without lab evidence.

Grape varieties

0/4 wine records have a supported grape field. Presence in this catalog does not measure grape demand or tell growers what to plant.