The cellar

Compare bottles

Find the differences that matter to your glass. Compare flavor, structure, alcohol, and how each bottle was made.

2 of 4 bottles

Show every field Clear

1 Good Liar

American IPA

Beer · IPA

83/100

Tasted

Remove

2 Other Half

All In

Beer · IPA

86/100

Tasted

Remove

The short version

Where they differ

Declared alcohol

  • 10.34%
  • 2<0.5%

Production

  • 1Dealcoholized
  • 2Naturally low alcohol

Flavor profile

  • 1Peach, Apricot, Lemon, Citrus, Stone fruit, Malt
  • 2Peach, Grapefruit, Mango

Structure, side by side

From our tastings. Each mark shows an assessed level, with the same scale for every bottle.

Sweetness

1Good LiarNot assessed

2Other HalfOff-dry

Body

1Good LiarNot assessed

2Other HalfMedium body

Look closer

The full comparison

Hiding 6 matching fields. Show every field

1 Good Liar

American IPA

  • Lowest price
  • Dealcoholized

2 Other Half

All In

  • Highest score
  • Producer-documented method
Taste
Score Differs

83/100

86/100

Verdict A balanced American IPA with peach, apricot and lemon, clean malt and firm hop bitterness. Fuller body and a dry, lingering finish give it a convincing shape. Other Half All In is a Brooklyn nonalcoholic hazy IPA under 0.5% ABV, hopped with Citra, Simcoe, and Centennial via arrested fermentation. Peach candy, ripe…
Flavor Differs Peach, Apricot, Lemon, Citrus, Stone fruit, Malt Peach, Grapefruit, Mango
Sweetness Differs — Off-dry
Body Differs — Medium body
Likeness — Reads as a real hazy IPA that never climbed past nonalcoholic — hops and haze do the structural work. Finish fades faster than a full-strength OH can.
Alcohol & production
Alcohol level Differs 0.34% <0.5%
Production Differs Dealcoholized Naturally low alcohol
Method Differs Undeclared Arrested fermentation
Product facts
Origin Columbus, Ohio, United States Brooklyn, New York, United States
Bottle size 12 fl oz (355 ml) can 12 oz can
Evidence
Last verified 2026-10-24 2026-10-07