The cellar
Compare bottles
Find the differences that matter to your glass. Compare flavor, structure, alcohol, and how each bottle was made.
The short version
Where they differ
Flavor profile
- Bottle 1White peach, Apple, Strawberry
- Bottle 2Apricot
- Bottle 3Red currant, Blackberry, Blossom
Structure, side by side
From our tastings. Each mark shows an assessed level, with the same scale for every bottle.
Sweetness
1GiesenOff-dry
2Thomson & ScottNot assessed
3Pierre ZéroNot assessed
Body
1GiesenLight body
2Thomson & ScottNot assessed
3Pierre ZéroLight body
Acidity
1GiesenBright acidity
2Thomson & ScottNot assessed
3Pierre ZéroBright acidity
Look closer
The full comparison
7 fields match. Differences are marked.
| Field |
2 Thomson & Scott |
3 Pierre Zéro |
|
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste | |||
| Record | Tasted | Tasted | Tasted |
| Score Differs | 86/100 |
84/100 |
77/100 |
| Verdict | Giesen ferments a full-strength Marlborough and Waipara rosé, then removes the alcohol with spinning cone technology. Less than 0.5% ABV. | A still dealcoholized rosé: summer berries and fresh apricot, soft and balanced, without a bead. | Pierre Zéro's Bag-in-Box rosé is three litres of dealcoholized French rosé from Maison Chavin, the range's pioneer since 2010: redcurrant and bilberry fruit,… |
| Flavor Differs | White peach, Apple, Strawberry | Apricot | Red currant, Blackberry, Blossom |
| Sweetness Differs | Off-dry | — | — |
| Body Differs | Light body | — | Light body |
| Acidity Differs | Bright acidity | — | Bright acidity |
| Likeness | It reads as rosé rather than pink soda: stone fruit and cranberry, off-dry, on a light frame. The short middle is the limit. | A soft still rosé, Provence-shaped: berries and apricot hold, and the Pinotage is color rather than tannin. The missing snap is the limit. | Fruit-forward rosé, not a savory one. Redcurrant and bilberry over gentle acidity, made to pour rather than to study. The shape is wine. The short, soft close is the limit. |
| Category | Wine | Wine | Wine |
| Style | Rosé | Rosé | Rosé |
| Alcohol & production | |||
| Alcohol level | <0.5% | <0.5% | <0.5% |
| Production | Dealcoholized | Dealcoholized | Dealcoholized |
| Method | Spinning cone | Spinning cone | Spinning cone |
| Product facts | |||
| Origin | Marlborough and Waipara, New Zealand | Western Cape, South Africa | France |
| Price Differs | Under $20 | $20–$29 | $20–$29 |
| Bottle size | 750 ml | 750 ml | 3 litres (bag-in-box) |
| Evidence | |||
| Verification | Producer documented | Producer documented | Producer documented |
| Sources | 4 sources | 5 sources | 6 sources |
| Last verified | 2026-10-18 | 2026-10-20 | 2026-10-03 |