The cellar

Compare bottles

Find the differences that matter to your glass. Compare flavor, structure, alcohol, and how each bottle was made.

3 of 4 bottles

Show every field Clear

1 1911 Established

Clear View Rosé Cider

Cider · Cider

81/100

Tasted

Remove

2 Jörg Geiger

WiesenObst Cider

Cider · Cider

86/100

Tasted

Remove

3 Jörg Geiger

WiesenObst Cider Rosé

Cider · Cider

85/100

Tasted

Remove

The short version

Where they differ

Sweetness

  • 1Off-dry
  • 2Sweet
  • 3Off-dry

Production

  • 1Dealcoholized
  • 2Hybrid
  • 3Hybrid

Flavor profile

  • 1Apple, Strawberry, Red berry, Cranberry
  • 2Apple, Pear, Floral, Cinnamon, Orchard fruit
  • 3Red berry

Structure, side by side

From our tastings. Each mark shows an assessed level, with the same scale for every bottle.

Sweetness

11911 EstablishedOff-dry

2WiesenObst CiderSweet

3WiesenObst Cider RoséOff-dry

Body

11911 EstablishedLight body

2WiesenObst CiderNot assessed

3WiesenObst Cider RoséNot assessed

Acidity

11911 EstablishedBright acidity

2WiesenObst CiderBright acidity

3WiesenObst Cider RoséBright acidity

Look closer

The full comparison

Hiding 6 matching fields. Show every field

1 1911 Established

Clear View Rosé Cider

  • Lowest price
  • Dealcoholized

2 Jörg Geiger

WiesenObst Cider

  • Highest score
  • Producer-documented method

3 Jörg Geiger

WiesenObst Cider Rosé

  • Producer-documented method
Taste
Score Differs

81/100

86/100

85/100

Verdict Fresh apple, strawberry, and red berry — crisp and tart, lightly sweet, lively acidity, a clean cranberry-apple finish. Generous, sweet apple and pear fruit, white-flower aromas and gentle cinnamon. Refreshing acidity and fine bubbles give the lingering orchard flavors lift an… Jörg Geiger's WiesenObst Rosé is dealcoholized cider cut with dealcoholized red wine, hops, herbs, and flowers. Under 0.5% ABV, 330 ml cans.
Flavor Differs Apple, Strawberry, Red berry, Cranberry Apple, Pear, Floral, Cinnamon, Orchard fruit Red berry
Sweetness Differs Off-dry Sweet Off-dry
Body Differs Light body — —
Likeness It tastes like rosé cider, not like pink wine: apple stays in front, red berry colors it, and the acid is the structure. Expressive orchard fruit, refreshing acidity and lively sparkle give the apple-and-pear profile a recognizable cider character, with gentle cinnamon adding depth. —
Alcohol & production
Production Differs Dealcoholized Hybrid Hybrid
Method Differs Undeclared Vacuum distillation Vacuum distillation
Product facts
Origin LaFayette, New York, United States Schlat, Germany Schlat, Germany
Price Differs Under $20 $20–$29 $20–$29
Bottle size 12 oz can 330 ml bottle 330 ml
Evidence
Sources 7 sources 2 sources 4 sources
Last verified 2026-10-18 2026-10-20 2026-10-24