The cellar
Compare bottles
Find the differences that matter to your glass. Compare flavor, structure, alcohol, and how each bottle was made.
1 1911 Established
Clear View Rosé Cider
81/100
Tasted
Remove 1911 Established Clear View Rosé Cider
2 Original Sin Cider
Widow Family Mix Pack (Original Sin's lineup)
78/100
Tasted
Remove Original Sin Cider Widow Family Mix Pack (Original Sin's lineup)
The short version
Where they differ
Sweetness
- Bottle 1Off-dry
- Bottle 2Off-dry
- Bottle 3Sweet
Declared alcohol
- Bottle 1<0.5%
- Bottle 20.0%
- Bottle 3<0.5%
Flavor profile
- Bottle 1Apple, Strawberry, Red berry, Cranberry
- Bottle 2Apple, Acetic, Blackberry
- Bottle 3Apple, Pear, Floral, Cinnamon, Orchard fruit
Structure, side by side
From our tastings. Each mark shows an assessed level, with the same scale for every bottle.
Sweetness
11911 EstablishedOff-dry
2Original Sin CiderOff-dry
3Jörg GeigerSweet
Body
11911 EstablishedLight body
2Original Sin CiderNot assessed
3Jörg GeigerNot assessed
Acidity
11911 EstablishedBright acidity
2Original Sin CiderBright acidity
3Jörg GeigerBright acidity
| Field |
2 Original Sin Cider |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste | |||
| Score Differs | 81/100 |
78/100 |
86/100 |
| Verdict | Fresh apple, strawberry, and red berry — crisp and tart, lightly sweet, lively acidity, a clean cranberry-apple finish. | Original Sin's Widow Family 12-pack is their nonalcoholic lineup: apple-cider-vinegar and fruit-juice based, monk-fruit sweetened, never alcohol-fermented; f… | Generous, sweet apple and pear fruit, white-flower aromas and gentle cinnamon. Refreshing acidity and fine bubbles give the lingering orchard flavors lift an… |
| Flavor Differs | Apple, Strawberry, Red berry, Cranberry | Apple, Acetic, Blackberry | Apple, Pear, Floral, Cinnamon, Orchard fruit |
| Sweetness Differs | Off-dry | Off-dry | Sweet |
| Body Differs | Light body | — | — |
| Likeness | It tastes like rosé cider, not like pink wine: apple stays in front, red berry colors it, and the acid is the structure. | — | Expressive orchard fruit, refreshing acidity and lively sparkle give the apple-and-pear profile a recognizable cider character, with gentle cinnamon adding depth. |
| Alcohol & production | |||
| Alcohol level Differs | <0.5% | 0.0% | <0.5% |
| Production Differs | Dealcoholized | Alternative | Hybrid |
| Method Differs | Undeclared | Formulated alternative | Vacuum distillation |
| Product facts | |||
| Origin | LaFayette, New York, United States | Brooklyn, New York, United States | Schlat, Germany |
| Price Differs | Under $20 | $20–$29 | $20–$29 |
| Bottle size | 12 oz can | 12 fl oz cans, sold as the Widow Family 12-pack across four flavors | 330 ml bottle |
| Evidence | |||
| Verification Differs | Producer documented | Secondary source | Producer documented |
| Sources | 7 sources | 5 sources | 2 sources |
| Last verified | 2026-10-18 | 2026-10-10 | 2026-10-20 |