The cellar
Compare bottles
Find the differences that matter to your glass. Compare flavor, structure, alcohol, and how each bottle was made.
The short version
Where they differ
Flavor profile
- Bottle 1Green apple, Pear, Citrus, Oak
- Bottle 2Pear, Apple, Pineapple, Lemon, Citrus, Mineral
- Bottle 3Apple, White peach
Structure, side by side
From our tastings. Each mark shows an assessed level, with the same scale for every bottle.
Sweetness
1RELAXOff-dry
2SummerlandOff-dry
3Villa AmélieOff-dry
Body
1RELAXLight body
2SummerlandNot assessed
3Villa AmélieVery light
Acidity
1RELAXSoft acidity
2SummerlandNot assessed
3Villa AmélieNot assessed
| Field |
2 Summerland |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Taste | |||
| Verdict | An approachable, fruit-forward Chardonnay with green apple, ripe pear, and subtle citrus. Light fizz refreshes a sweet, softly acidic palate, though the thin… | Soft, fruit-forward Chardonnay with pear, apple and a citrus finish, but this bottle showed a corked, musty character. The 81/100 reflects apparent underlyin… | Golden Delicious apple and white peach lead a thin, fresh, off-dry Chardonnay. Smooth in the mouth, light on the close, and short of weight in the middle. |
| Flavor Differs | Green apple, Pear, Citrus, Oak | Pear, Apple, Pineapple, Lemon, Citrus, Mineral | Apple, White peach |
| Body Differs | Light body | — | Very light |
| Acidity Differs | Soft acidity | — | — |
| Likeness | The fruit hints at Chardonnay, but the light body, sweetness, soft acidity, and short finish leave it less convincing as a traditional wine. | — | The apple and white peach aromatics fit a familiar Chardonnay profile. The thin palate offers limited structural weight, so the vinous impression is stronger on the nose than in the mouth. |
| Alcohol & production | |||
| Method Differs | Vacuum distillation | Undeclared | Vacuum distillation |
| Product facts | |||
| Origin | Mosel Valley, Germany | Santa Barbara County, United States | Languedoc, France |
| Bottle size | 750 ml bottle | 750 ml | 750 ml |
| Evidence | |||
| Verification Differs | Producer documented | Bottle verified | Producer documented |
| Sources | 3 sources | 4 sources | 7 sources |
| Last verified | 2026-10-03 | 2026-10-24 | 2026-10-24 |